Private for longer
How to back tomorrow's winners
Private equity investment trusts are coming into sharper focus as companies stay private for longer and in some cases, question whether an IPO is the right call. Businesses can now access significant amounts of private capital without a public listing, which means more growth and value creation is happening away from the stock market.
Annabel Brodie-Smith, Director of the Association of Investment Companies (AIC), said: “Private equity investment trusts offer access to a growing private market. The investment trust structure is perfectly suited to private equity. It gives investors access to a diversified portfolio of private companies, while allowing managers to take a long-term approach, rather than worrying about being forced to sell investments at the wrong time.”
“The investment trust structure is perfectly suited to private equity. It gives investors access to a diversified portfolio of private companies, while allowing managers to take a long-term approach, rather than worrying about being forced to sell investments at the wrong time.”
To discuss the opportunities facing private equity investment trusts, a webinar was held by the Association of Investment Companies (AIC), featuring Richard Hickman, Managing Director of HarbourVest Global Private Equity, managed by HarbourVest Partners, Luke Finch, Manager of HgCapital Trust and Partner at Hg and Luke Mason, Principal at Neuberger Private Equity Partners. Their comments are collated below alongside views from managers across the private equity sector on discounts and the biggest misconceptions people have about private equity.
Are the discounts of private equity investment trusts justified?
Richard Hickman, Managing Director of HarbourVest Global Private Equity (HVPE), managed by HarbourVest Partners, said: “The recent discounts seen across the listed private equity sector have created understandable debate around portfolio valuations. In our view, the strongest evidence of value comes when assets are realised. HVPE’s targeted asset sale completed in December 2025 at a blended 6% discount to NAV, in sharp contrast to the discount of about 30% on the shares, demonstrated that underlying valuations remain broadly supported by market transactions.”
Colm Walsh, Portfolio Manager of ICG Enterprise Trust, said: “Discounts in the listed private equity space are materially wider than the discounts we see in the secondary market and the values at which we are realising assets. ICG Enterprise Trust sold a portion of its portfolio in the private secondaries market last year at a 5.5% discount, and our most recent half-year results included 24 full exits at an average 9.4% uplift to carrying value. Against that evidence, shares trading at around a 32% discount to NAV suggest an attractive entry point. One of the strengths of the investment trust structure is that the share price allows investors to express a view on the valuations of the unlisted investments within the portfolio, without forcing the underlying portfolio to sell assets. That’s a powerful structural advantage. The question is whether today’s discounts have taken that mechanism too far.”
“Discounts in the listed private equity space are materially wider than the discounts we see in the secondary market and the values at which we are realising assets.”
Charlotte Morris, Lead Manager at Pantheon International (PIN) and Partner at Pantheon, said: “While it is encouraging to see that the discounts in the private equity investment trust have narrowed significantly from where they stood 12 months ago, we believe that they are still too wide. If we look at the companies in PIN’s portfolio, our PE managers consistently sell them at a significant uplift to their holding value. Even in a more challenging exit environment, the weighted average uplift on the exits in PIN’s portfolio was 18% for the financial year ended 31 May 2026; the weighted average uplift over the past ten years is 28%.
“In our view, this demonstrates that there is embedded value in the portfolio and that actually our managers take a conservative approach to valuing their portfolio companies – they don’t write them up aggressively when the public markets rise and therefore do not need to write them down sharply when the public markets fall. Finally, it should be noted that our managers’ valuations are subject to audit once a year and PIN’s own NAV is also audited, which gives us further confidence in the valuation process.”
“There are approximately a dozen private equity focused investment trusts listed on the London Stock Exchange. While they all sit within the ‘Private Equity’ segment of investment trusts, investors often have a tendency to see them as a homogeneous group.”
The biggest misconceptions about private equity
Richard Pindar, Manager of Literacy Capital, said: “There are approximately a dozen private equity focused investment trusts listed on the London Stock Exchange. While they all sit within the ‘Private Equity’ segment of investment trusts, investors often have a tendency to see them as a homogeneous group. However, there are some significant differences between these trusts.
"Literacy Capital is part of a smaller category of private equity investment trusts that make investments directly from their own balance sheets into underlying portfolio companies. This direct investment structure allows for a more focused approach and increased exposure to assets in which we have the most conviction, while also enabling us to support management teams generating long-term growth and value creation.
“Unlike the structures of traditional limited partnerships, which encourage (and ultimately force) private equity managers to sell their investments within a set timeframe, this structure allows the fund to own successful assets for longer and realise investments at the best times to maximise value for investors.”
Alan Gauld, Managing Director and Lead Portfolio Manager of Patria Private Equity Trust, said: “Private equity investing has evolved a great deal over the last two decades, but market perception still needs to catch up. For example, the misconception that private equity investing is just leveraged listed equity with some cost cutting thrown in – buy something, gear it up, remove costs and ride the market – is very common. This isn’t an investment model I recognise at all, and certainly isn’t what typically drives private equity returns.
“Private equity’s power lies in the ‘active ownership’ governance model. PE firms take a majority stake in the companies they invest in which comes with a seat on the board, giving them a much greater say in how the company is run and – importantly – the clout to actually change the things that aren’t working so well. Listed equity doesn’t usually have that advantage.
“Private equity managers nowadays are also sector specialists, bringing a toolkit which is far more sophisticated compared to a decade ago for the benefit of the companies they invest in. Functional experience, data or AI insight and M&A professionals to assist with bolt-on acquisitions and integration go a long way in helping to accelerate revenue and earnings growth for many PE-backed businesses.”
“The most enduring misconception is that private equity’s returns are driven by excessive debt and financial engineering, rather than by building better businesses. At Oakley, we back ambitious founders, combining capital, specialist expertise and hands-on ownership to create value, through investment in technology, acquisitions or international expansion. Earnings growth, not leverage, is the most important driver of our returns.”
Steven Tredget, Manager of Oakley Capital Investments, said: “The most enduring misconception is that private equity’s returns are driven by excessive debt and financial engineering, rather than by building better businesses. At Oakley, we back ambitious founders, combining capital, specialist expertise and hands-on ownership to create value, through investment in technology, acquisitions or international expansion. Earnings growth, not leverage, is the most important driver of our returns.
“Private equity is a wide-ranging asset class that spans everything from venture capital to mega-cap buyouts, yet it is discussed as one uniform investment class. We need to encourage a debate that reflects that diversity in the same way that public equities, real estate or commodities are discussed.
“The industry needs to make the model and the opportunity more tangible. We should show how businesses grow under our ownership, give founders a platform to explain our contribution, and demonstrate how that translates into shareholder returns. We also need to reinforce the message that private equity is not reserved for institutions or the very wealthy, with listed private equity trusts already providing liquid access to the asset class.”
For the full press release, please read it here.