Sister funds
88% of trusts have beaten sister funds over ten years
A majority of investment trusts with open-ended “sister funds” have outperformed those funds over the past ten years, according to research released today by the Association of Investment Companies (AIC).
In 28 out of 32 cases (88%) where an investment trust and an open-ended fund have had the same fund manager for the past ten years, the investment trust has outperformed.
“It’s good to see investment trusts’ natural advantages help managers to generate strong performance over the past decade. Being able to gear is clearly helpful, as is the flexibility to invest in less liquid assets.”
Trusts have also fared well over shorter time periods. Over both one year and three years, 83% of trusts have outperformed funds with the same manager, while over five years, 73% of trusts have delivered higher returns than their sister funds.
Nick Britton, Research Director of the Association of Investment Companies (AIC), said: “It’s good to see investment trusts’ natural advantages help managers to generate strong performance over the past decade. Being able to gear is clearly helpful, as is the flexibility to invest in less liquid assets. With investment trusts, managers can also pick their moment to buy and sell investments, which isn’t always possible with funds that have to follow investment flows.
“This research shouldn’t be taken to mean that investment trusts will always outperform, but it does suggest that long-term investors who ignore trusts may be missing out.”
How much did investment trusts outperform?
Over the past ten years, the average investment trust with a sister fund returned an extra £37 per £100 invested compared to the fund, or an additional 1.7 percentage points of return per year.
1 year
3 years
5 years
10 years
No. of sister pairs in which investment trust outperformed open-ended fund over the period
34 out of 41
33 out of 40
29 out of 40
28 out of 32
% of sister pairs in which investment trust outperformed open-ended fund over the period
83%
73%
88%
Average investment trust outperformance (additional £ generated by investment trust per £100 invested in sister fund)
£4
£12
£8
£37
Average investment trust outperformance (% p.a.)
4.4%
3.3%
1.3%
1.7%
Source: theaic.co.uk / Morningstar (based on share price total returns to 30/09/26).
Over one year, the average investment trust returned an additional £4 per £100 invested compared to its open-ended sister fund, over three years £12, and over five years an additional £8 for every £100 invested. In percentage terms, the outperformance amounted to 4.4, 3.2 and 1.3 percentage points per year for the same time periods.